Electronic Case Filings

E-Dockets

U-Number Search:

Case: 15929
Horizontal Bar

Summary: In the matter, on the Commission's own motion, to initiate a contested case proceeding involving Consumers Energy Company, Michigan Consolidated Gas Company, Michigan Gas Utilities Corporation, and SEMCO Energy Gas Company to investigate whether any clarifications, revisions, or additions should be made to certain approved gas customer choice tariffs.

Industry: Gas

Company(s): Commission's Own Motion

Open Date: 4/16/2009

Order Dates: 4/16/2009, 10/13/2009

Click on the Document # to view the PDF file. A document # ending with an N, was not electronically filed or it has been deemed confidential. If you have questions, please contact the Michigan Public Service Commission at (517) 241-6180.

Document No. File Date Filed by On Behalf of Type Description Pgs

0080 10/13/2009 Press Release 1

0079 10/13/2009 MPSC Order Denies Direct Energy Services leave to appeal; approves settlement agreement 48

0078 10/13/2009 Dempsey Constellation NewEnergy-Gas Division, LLC Proof of Service Constellation NewEnergy-Gas Division LLC's Statement of Non-Objection 3

0077 10/13/2009 Dempsey Constellation NewEnergy-Gas Division, LLC Other Constellation NewEnergy-Gas Division, LLC's Statement of Non-Objection 2

0076 10/13/2009 Sattler MPSC Staff Settlement Agreement Revised Settlement Agreement to include missing signature and missing attachment 39

0075 10/13/2009 Nickerson, Jr. Administrative Law Judges Transmittal 1

0074 10/12/2009 Sattler MPSC Staff Settlement Agreement Settlement Agreement 15

0073 10/12/2009 Sattler MPSC Staff Response Reply in Opposition to Direct Energy Services LLC's Application for Leave to Appeal 41

0072 10/12/2009 Wellman Michigan Gas Utilities Corporation and SEMCO Energy Gas Company Response to Appeal 6

0071 10/9/2009 McQuillan Consumers Energy Company Response In Opposition to Direct Energy Services Application for Leave to Appeal Ruling Denying Intervention 9

0070 10/7/2009 Prawdzik Administrative Law Judges Scheduling Memo 1

0069 10/5/2009 Schroeder Metro Court Reporters Transcript Vol 3, 09-22-2009, Motion hearing 38

0068 9/30/2009 Liskey Commerce Energy Appearance Appearance 1

0067 9/28/2009 Nickerson, Jr. Administrative Law Judges Scheduling Memo 1

0066 9/28/2009 Schneidewind Direct Energy Services, LLC Appeal Application For Leave To Appeal September 22, 2009 Ruling Denying Petition To Intervene 15

0065 9/22/2009 Dempsey Constellation NewEnergy-Gas Division, LLC Appearance Appearance of John M. Dempsey on Behalf of Constellation NewEnergy-Gas Division LLC 1

0064 9/21/2009 Nickerson, Jr. Administrative Law Judges Scheduling Memo 1

0063 9/21/2009 McQuillan Consumers Energy Company Objections Consumers Energy Companys Objection to Petition for Late Intervention 6

0062 9/21/2009 Sattler MPSC Staff Response Reply in Opposition to Direct Energy Services LLC's Petition for Late Intervention 14

0061 9/21/2009 Nickerson, Jr. Administrative Law Judges Scheduling Memo 1

0060 9/9/2009 Sattler MPSC Staff Proof of Service MPSC Staff's Answer to Commerce Energy's First Discovery Request 2

0059 9/8/2009 Schneidewind Direct Energy Services LLC Motion Motion to Grant Petition for Late Intervention and Notice of Hearing 9

0058 9/8/2009 Wellman SEMCO Energy Gas Company Proof of Service of service of SEMCO's Response to Universal's First Discovery Request 2

0057 9/8/2009 Solo Michigan Consolidated Gas Company Proof of Service Response to Universal Gas & Electric's First Discovery Request 3

0056 9/8/2009 Wellman Michigan Gas Utilities Corporation Proof of Service of service of MGUC's Response to Universal's First Discovery Request 2

0055 9/3/2009 McQuillan Consumers Energy Company Proof of Service Discovery Response 15929-CEM-CE-1 4

0054 9/2/2009 Sattler MPSC Staff Proof of Service MPSC Staff's Answer to MXenergy's First Discovery Request 2

0053 8/31/2009 Sattler MPSC Staff Proof of Service MPSC Staff's Answer to Lakeshore Energy Services, LLC, et al's First Discovery Request 2

0052 8/26/2009 Gensch, Jr. Universal Gas & Electric dba Commerce Energy of Michigan Proof of Service First Discovery Requests to MPSC Staff 2

0051 8/26/2009 Gensch, Jr. Universal Gas & Electric dba Commerce Energy of Michigan Proof of Service First Discovery Requests to SEMCO Energy Gas Company 2

0050 8/26/2009 Gensch, Jr. Universal Gas & Electric dba Commerce Energy of Michigan Proof of Service First Discovery Requests to Michigan Gas Utilities Corporation 2

0049 8/26/2009 Gensch, Jr. Universal Gas & Electric dba Commerce Energy of Michigan Proof of Service First Discovery Requests to Consumers Energy 2

0048 8/26/2009 Gensch, Jr. Universal Gas & Electric dba Commerce Energy of Michigan Proof of Service First Discovery Requests to Michigan Consolidated Gas Company 2

0047 8/19/2009 Nelson Mxenergy, Inc. Proof of Service Certificate of Service regarding Mxenergy, Inc.'s First Discovery Requests to The Michigan Public Service Commission Staff 4

0046 8/7/2009 Wolter Lakeshore Energy Services, LLC., My Choice Energy, LLC, Volunteer Energy Services, Inc. Proof of Service First discovery request to MPSC Staff 3

0045 8/5/2009 Schroeder Metro Court Reporters Transcript Volume 2, 07-21-2009, Motion hearing 8

0044 8/5/2009 Sattler MPSC Staff Proof of Service MPSC Staff's Answer to IGS's First Discovery Request 2

0043 8/4/2009 Dempsey Interstate Gas Supply, Inc. Proof of Service Interstate Gas Supply, Inc.'s First Discovery Request to MPSC Staff 3

0042 8/3/2009 Sattler MPSC Staff Proof of Service Supplemental Proof of Service of Direct Testimony of Sheila K. Cornfield 1

0041 7/31/2009 McNea MPSC Staff Testimony & Exhibits Testimony and Exhibits of Sheila Cornfield 65

0040 7/21/2009 Nickerson, Jr. Administrative Law Judges Scheduling Memo 1

0039 7/13/2009 Nickerson, Jr. Administrative Law Judges Scheduling Memo 1

0038 7/13/2009 Nelson MXenergy Inc. Notice of Hearing with MX Energy's Late Filed Petition to Intervene and Certificate of Service 9

0037 6/22/2009 Schroeder Metro Court Reporters Transcript Vol 1, 06-09-2009, Prehearing 16

0036 6/12/2009 Sattler MPSC Staff Response Supplemental Response in Opposition to MichCon's Motion to Dismiss Contested Case Proceeding 7

0035 6/10/2009 Dempsey Interstate Gas Supply, Inc. Intervention Interstate Gas Supply, Inc.'s Petition For Leave to Intervene 8

0034 6/9/2009 Nickerson, Jr. Administrative Law Judges Scheduling Memo 1

0033 6/8/2009 Witte Universal Gas and Electric dba Commerce Energy of Michigan Appearance Entry of Appearance in an Administrative Hearing 1

0032 6/8/2009 Gensch, Jr. Universal Gas and Electric dba Commerce Energy of Michigan Appearance Entry of Appearance in an Administrative Hearing 1

0031 6/8/2009 Field Universal Gas and Electric dba Commerce Energy of Michigan Appearance Entry of Appearance in an Administrative Hearing 1

0030 6/8/2009 Dempsey Interstate Gas Supply, Inc. Appearance Appearance of John M. Dempsey on Behalf of Interstate Gas Supply, Inc. 1

0029 6/8/2009 Solo Michigan Consolidated Gas Company Proof of Service Mailing Notice of Hearing to all cities, incorporated villages, townships and counties in MichCon's service area, and all intervenors in Case No. U-13898 19

0028 6/8/2009 Solo Michigan Consolidated Gas Company Affidavit Publication 11

0027 6/8/2009 Solo Michigan Consolidated Gas Company Appearance 1

0026 6/8/2009 Polack Consumers Energy Company Affidavit Publication of Notice of Hearing 19

0025 6/5/2009 Sattler MPSC Staff Proof of Service Supplemental Proof of Service of response to motion 2

0024 6/4/2009 Sattler MPSC Staff Response Response in Opposition to Mich Con's Motion to Dismiss Contested Case Proceeding 9

0023 6/4/2009 McQuillan Consumers Energy Company Appearance Appearance of Raymond E. McQuillan 1

0022 6/4/2009 Dempsey National Energy Marketers Association Intervention National Energy Marketers Association's Petition For Leave to Intervene; Appearance of John M. Dempsey on Behalf of National Energy Marketers Association 9

0021 6/3/2009 Chambers Consumers Energy Company Appearance Appearance of H. Richard Chambers 1

0020 6/3/2009 Wellman SEMCO Energy Gas Company Affidavit Affidavit of Mailing and Proofs of Publication 16

0019 6/2/2009 Wellman SEMCO Energy Gas Company Appearance Cover, Proof and Appearances of Wellman and Bloomberg 4

0018 6/2/2009 Wellman Michigan Gas Utilities Corporation Appearance Cover, Proof and Appearances of Wellman and Bloomberg 4

0017 6/2/2009 Bloomberg SEMCO Energy, Inc. and Michigan Gas Utilities Corporation Appearance 3

0016 6/2/2009 Ashton U.S. Gas & Electric, Inc. Petition Petition of U.S. Gas and Electric, Inc. for Leave to Intervene, Appearance, and Certificate of Service 7

0015 6/2/2009 Wolter Lakeshore Energy Services, LLC., My Choice Energy, LLC, Volunteer Energy Services, Inc. Appearance Appearance 1

0014 6/2/2009 Wolter Lakeshore Energy Services LLC, My Choice Energy LLC, Volunteer Energy Services Inc. Petition Intervene 8

0013 6/2/2009 Wellman Michigan Gas Utilities Corporation Affidavit Affidavit of Mailing and Proofs of Publication 17

0012 6/1/2009 Middleton Michigan Consolidated Gas Company Motion Motion to Dismiss 13

0011 5/29/2009 Field Universal Gas and Electric dba Commerce Energy Petition Universal Gas & Electric dba Commerce Energy of Michigan's Petition for Leave to Intervene 6

0010 5/22/2009 Polack Consumers Energy Company Proof of Service Notice of Hearing 24

0009 5/11/2009 Sattler MPSC Staff Appearance 2

0008 5/8/2009 Kunkle MPSC Staff Notice of Hearing Prehearing 6-9-09 11

0007 4/30/2009 Fletcher Comments 1

0006 4/28/2009 Dempsey Constellation NewEnergy-Gas Division, LLC Intervention Petition to Intervene and Appearance 7

0005 4/21/2009 Kunkle MPSC Transmittal E-mail to Witte confirming receipt of payment 1

0004 4/21/2009 Witte Universal Gas & Electric Corporation Other Payment made in accordance with Commission order 1

0003 4/20/2009 Prawdzik Administrative Law Judges Scheduling Memo 1

0002 4/16/2009 Press Release 2

0001 4/16/2009 MPSC Order Initiates contested case proceeding 20

Document No.	File Date	Filed by	On Behalf of	Type	Description	Pgs
0080	10/13/2009			Press Release		1
0079	10/13/2009		MPSC	Order	Denies Direct Energy Services leave to appeal; approves settlement agreement	48
0078	10/13/2009	Dempsey	Constellation NewEnergy-Gas Division, LLC	Proof of Service	Constellation NewEnergy-Gas Division LLC's Statement of Non-Objection	3
0077	10/13/2009	Dempsey	Constellation NewEnergy-Gas Division, LLC	Other	Constellation NewEnergy-Gas Division, LLC's Statement of Non-Objection	2
0076	10/13/2009	Sattler	MPSC Staff	Settlement Agreement	Revised Settlement Agreement to include missing signature and missing attachment	39
0075	10/13/2009	Nickerson, Jr.	Administrative Law Judges	Transmittal		1
0074	10/12/2009	Sattler	MPSC Staff	Settlement Agreement	Settlement Agreement	15
0073	10/12/2009	Sattler	MPSC Staff	Response	Reply in Opposition to Direct Energy Services LLC's Application for Leave to Appeal	41
0072	10/12/2009	Wellman	Michigan Gas Utilities Corporation and SEMCO Energy Gas Company	Response	to Appeal	6
0071	10/9/2009	McQuillan	Consumers Energy Company	Response	In Opposition to Direct Energy Services Application for Leave to Appeal Ruling Denying Intervention	9
0070	10/7/2009	Prawdzik	Administrative Law Judges	Scheduling Memo		1
0069	10/5/2009	Schroeder	Metro Court Reporters	Transcript	Vol 3, 09-22-2009, Motion hearing	38
0068	9/30/2009	Liskey	Commerce Energy	Appearance	Appearance	1
0067	9/28/2009	Nickerson, Jr.	Administrative Law Judges	Scheduling Memo		1
0066	9/28/2009	Schneidewind	Direct Energy Services, LLC	Appeal	Application For Leave To Appeal September 22, 2009 Ruling Denying Petition To Intervene	15
0065	9/22/2009	Dempsey	Constellation NewEnergy-Gas Division, LLC	Appearance	Appearance of John M. Dempsey on Behalf of Constellation NewEnergy-Gas Division LLC	1
0064	9/21/2009	Nickerson, Jr.	Administrative Law Judges	Scheduling Memo		1
0063	9/21/2009	McQuillan	Consumers Energy Company	Objections	Consumers Energy Companys Objection to Petition for Late Intervention	6
0062	9/21/2009	Sattler	MPSC Staff	Response	Reply in Opposition to Direct Energy Services LLC's Petition for Late Intervention	14
0061	9/21/2009	Nickerson, Jr.	Administrative Law Judges	Scheduling Memo		1
0060	9/9/2009	Sattler	MPSC Staff	Proof of Service	MPSC Staff's Answer to Commerce Energy's First Discovery Request	2
0059	9/8/2009	Schneidewind	Direct Energy Services LLC	Motion	Motion to Grant Petition for Late Intervention and Notice of Hearing	9
0058	9/8/2009	Wellman	SEMCO Energy Gas Company	Proof of Service	of service of SEMCO's Response to Universal's First Discovery Request	2
0057	9/8/2009	Solo	Michigan Consolidated Gas Company	Proof of Service	Response to Universal Gas & Electric's First Discovery Request	3
0056	9/8/2009	Wellman	Michigan Gas Utilities Corporation	Proof of Service	of service of MGUC's Response to Universal's First Discovery Request	2
0055	9/3/2009	McQuillan	Consumers Energy Company	Proof of Service	Discovery Response 15929-CEM-CE-1	4
0054	9/2/2009	Sattler	MPSC Staff	Proof of Service	MPSC Staff's Answer to MXenergy's First Discovery Request	2
0053	8/31/2009	Sattler	MPSC Staff	Proof of Service	MPSC Staff's Answer to Lakeshore Energy Services, LLC, et al's First Discovery Request	2
0052	8/26/2009	Gensch, Jr.	Universal Gas & Electric dba Commerce Energy of Michigan	Proof of Service	First Discovery Requests to MPSC Staff	2
0051	8/26/2009	Gensch, Jr.	Universal Gas & Electric dba Commerce Energy of Michigan	Proof of Service	First Discovery Requests to SEMCO Energy Gas Company	2
0050	8/26/2009	Gensch, Jr.	Universal Gas & Electric dba Commerce Energy of Michigan	Proof of Service	First Discovery Requests to Michigan Gas Utilities Corporation	2
0049	8/26/2009	Gensch, Jr.	Universal Gas & Electric dba Commerce Energy of Michigan	Proof of Service	First Discovery Requests to Consumers Energy	2
0048	8/26/2009	Gensch, Jr.	Universal Gas & Electric dba Commerce Energy of Michigan	Proof of Service	First Discovery Requests to Michigan Consolidated Gas Company	2
0047	8/19/2009	Nelson	Mxenergy, Inc.	Proof of Service	Certificate of Service regarding Mxenergy, Inc.'s First Discovery Requests to The Michigan Public Service Commission Staff	4
0046	8/7/2009	Wolter	Lakeshore Energy Services, LLC., My Choice Energy, LLC, Volunteer Energy Services, Inc.	Proof of Service	First discovery request to MPSC Staff	3
0045	8/5/2009	Schroeder	Metro Court Reporters	Transcript	Volume 2, 07-21-2009, Motion hearing	8
0044	8/5/2009	Sattler	MPSC Staff	Proof of Service	MPSC Staff's Answer to IGS's First Discovery Request	2
0043	8/4/2009	Dempsey	Interstate Gas Supply, Inc.	Proof of Service	Interstate Gas Supply, Inc.'s First Discovery Request to MPSC Staff	3
0042	8/3/2009	Sattler	MPSC Staff	Proof of Service	Supplemental Proof of Service of Direct Testimony of Sheila K. Cornfield	1
0041	7/31/2009	McNea	MPSC Staff	Testimony & Exhibits	Testimony and Exhibits of Sheila Cornfield	65
0040	7/21/2009	Nickerson, Jr.	Administrative Law Judges	Scheduling Memo		1
0039	7/13/2009	Nickerson, Jr.	Administrative Law Judges	Scheduling Memo		1
0038	7/13/2009	Nelson	MXenergy Inc.	Notice of Hearing	with MX Energy's Late Filed Petition to Intervene and Certificate of Service	9
0037	6/22/2009	Schroeder	Metro Court Reporters	Transcript	Vol 1, 06-09-2009, Prehearing	16
0036	6/12/2009	Sattler	MPSC Staff	Response	Supplemental Response in Opposition to MichCon's Motion to Dismiss Contested Case Proceeding	7
0035	6/10/2009	Dempsey	Interstate Gas Supply, Inc.	Intervention	Interstate Gas Supply, Inc.'s Petition For Leave to Intervene	8
0034	6/9/2009	Nickerson, Jr.	Administrative Law Judges	Scheduling Memo		1
0033	6/8/2009	Witte	Universal Gas and Electric dba Commerce Energy of Michigan	Appearance	Entry of Appearance in an Administrative Hearing	1
0032	6/8/2009	Gensch, Jr.	Universal Gas and Electric dba Commerce Energy of Michigan	Appearance	Entry of Appearance in an Administrative Hearing	1
0031	6/8/2009	Field	Universal Gas and Electric dba Commerce Energy of Michigan	Appearance	Entry of Appearance in an Administrative Hearing	1
0030	6/8/2009	Dempsey	Interstate Gas Supply, Inc.	Appearance	Appearance of John M. Dempsey on Behalf of Interstate Gas Supply, Inc.	1
0029	6/8/2009	Solo	Michigan Consolidated Gas Company	Proof of Service	Mailing Notice of Hearing to all cities, incorporated villages, townships and counties in MichCon's service area, and all intervenors in Case No. U-13898	19
0028	6/8/2009	Solo	Michigan Consolidated Gas Company	Affidavit	Publication	11
0027	6/8/2009	Solo	Michigan Consolidated Gas Company	Appearance		1
0026	6/8/2009	Polack	Consumers Energy Company	Affidavit	Publication of Notice of Hearing	19
0025	6/5/2009	Sattler	MPSC Staff	Proof of Service	Supplemental Proof of Service of response to motion	2
0024	6/4/2009	Sattler	MPSC Staff	Response	Response in Opposition to Mich Con's Motion to Dismiss Contested Case Proceeding	9
0023	6/4/2009	McQuillan	Consumers Energy Company	Appearance	Appearance of Raymond E. McQuillan	1
0022	6/4/2009	Dempsey	National Energy Marketers Association	Intervention	National Energy Marketers Association's Petition For Leave to Intervene; Appearance of John M. Dempsey on Behalf of National Energy Marketers Association	9
0021	6/3/2009	Chambers	Consumers Energy Company	Appearance	Appearance of H. Richard Chambers	1
0020	6/3/2009	Wellman	SEMCO Energy Gas Company	Affidavit	Affidavit of Mailing and Proofs of Publication	16
0019	6/2/2009	Wellman	SEMCO Energy Gas Company	Appearance	Cover, Proof and Appearances of Wellman and Bloomberg	4
0018	6/2/2009	Wellman	Michigan Gas Utilities Corporation	Appearance	Cover, Proof and Appearances of Wellman and Bloomberg	4
0017	6/2/2009	Bloomberg	SEMCO Energy, Inc. and Michigan Gas Utilities Corporation	Appearance		3
0016	6/2/2009	Ashton	U.S. Gas & Electric, Inc.	Petition	Petition of U.S. Gas and Electric, Inc. for Leave to Intervene, Appearance, and Certificate of Service	7
0015	6/2/2009	Wolter	Lakeshore Energy Services, LLC., My Choice Energy, LLC, Volunteer Energy Services, Inc.	Appearance	Appearance	1
0014	6/2/2009	Wolter	Lakeshore Energy Services LLC, My Choice Energy LLC, Volunteer Energy Services Inc.	Petition	Intervene	8
0013	6/2/2009	Wellman	Michigan Gas Utilities Corporation	Affidavit	Affidavit of Mailing and Proofs of Publication	17
0012	6/1/2009	Middleton	Michigan Consolidated Gas Company	Motion	Motion to Dismiss	13
0011	5/29/2009	Field	Universal Gas and Electric dba Commerce Energy	Petition	Universal Gas & Electric dba Commerce Energy of Michigan's Petition for Leave to Intervene	6
0010	5/22/2009	Polack	Consumers Energy Company	Proof of Service	Notice of Hearing	24
0009	5/11/2009	Sattler	MPSC Staff	Appearance		2
0008	5/8/2009	Kunkle	MPSC Staff	Notice of Hearing	Prehearing 6-9-09	11
0007	4/30/2009	Fletcher		Comments		1
0006	4/28/2009	Dempsey	Constellation NewEnergy-Gas Division, LLC	Intervention	Petition to Intervene and Appearance	7
0005	4/21/2009	Kunkle	MPSC	Transmittal	E-mail to Witte confirming receipt of payment	1
0004	4/21/2009	Witte	Universal Gas & Electric Corporation	Other	Payment made in accordance with Commission order	1
0003	4/20/2009	Prawdzik	Administrative Law Judges	Scheduling Memo		1
0002	4/16/2009			Press Release		2
0001	4/16/2009		MPSC	Order	Initiates contested case proceeding	20